The Osteen Question

Fr. Joseph Huneycutt and I are disagreeing about Joel Osteen over at Orthodixie. You may care to traipse over there to see what's going on. I don't want to reiterate the arguments here, but I want to emphasize that I'm a fan of Fr. Joseph and his blog. I have disagreements with just about everyone about lots of things, and I don't take these things personally.

What do I like about Osteen?
He's pleasant.
He wants people to succeed in life.
He's positive.
He urges people to rely on God.
He urges the adoption of good habits including politeness, civility, patience, understanding, charity, and so on.


What don't I like about Osteen?
He's not Orthodox.
His sweet sermons begin to grate on me after ten minutes.
I'm uncertain about whether there's any systematic theological content.
I'm uncertain what role the New Testament plays in his ministry, other than mentioning Christ, utilizing an immersion baptismal rite, and so on. One year's Easter message talked about the "can-do" Resurrection, which I'm still puzzling over.

I've watched a few sermons, and I know a few people who like him. You know, one thing I've admired about Protestantism is its high standard of personal holiness. Osteen seems to inspire people to act well and to rely on God.

It reminds me of the old joke about would happen to an unattended umbrella in Methodist and RC churches on a rainy day--the owner would get back his umbrella in the Methodist church. I came across this joke again--at Arturo's blog I think--and I'm grateful for the reminder. At the risk of overstretching an analogy, let me say that Osteen leaves me with the impression that he would exhort his followers not to glom umbrellas. You can say what you want about the pedestrian nature of bourgeois virtues, but I'm all for them.

If my impression is correct, then I'm not interested in seeing Osteen unfairly dumped on.

Third Romism Rolls On, Maybe

Does your blood boil? Mine does. The pro-Western, pro-democracy, pro-market underdog, Georgia, gets kicked around by the Russian bully...again.

Well, here's another view.

What is the motivation behind Georgia's urge to join NATO? To get away from the traditional Russian interference in Georgia's affairs. Present-day Georgia contains two regions that want to break away from Georgia. NATO membership would hinder Russia's support for the two break-away regions.

Let's get real about NATO. It's a military alliance, not a democracy-spreading miracle. Its primary purpose is to oppose Russian expansionism. That's the attraction that membership provides for former Soviet satellites and republics. Russian membership in NATO would not only alienate the former Warsaw Pact members, but also render it ineffective--similar to including the entire world in a military alliance. Why shouldn't Russia be upset at the prospect of new NATO members outside Eastern Europe encircling from the South?

Let's go a step further. Vladimir Putin is very aware that his bountiful oil revenue is a cyclical phenomenon. He's arguably an expert on energy; he did his dissertation on the subject. That's quite a contrast to the hysterical and self-absorbed Western media that can't handle an economic explanation that takes longer than five seconds. Putin is rolling in dough right now, but that bounty is about to dry up with the global economic slowdown. Now is the opportunity to send the right message and set up the right bargaining chips on the Georgia issue as well as the larger NATO issue involving both Georgia and Ukraine. He's seizing the opportunity with gusto, and he's truly screwing with Georgia by cutting the country in half. Never say that Putin doesn't have a sense of humor.

Now, I haven't even begun to talk about the parallels operating in Georgia and Kosovo. Other folks have talked about that aspect at length, and everyone I've read is correct--Georgia is a continuation of the Kosovo principle.

Yeah, my blood boils...but...don't you think that someone should get nominated for 2008 Moron Of The Year for giving Russia this golden opportunity?

Popular Preacher's Perks

Joel Osteen's wife has been sued for assaulting a flight attendant, and the trial judge encountered problems in seating jurors. A significant problem was the number of potential jurors whom had been helped by Rev. Osteen's ministry and wouldn't be impartial.

This is one of the perks awaiting the next St. John Chrysostom!

It may not be much, but let's face it. In a world in which parishioners would rather keep up with the latest MP3 player than pay their priests decently, every little bit helps.

Gap Pap

Gabriel hosted a lively discussion about Orthodoxy's "filling the gaps". As usual, I averred another view. Orthodoxy is about an alternative, not filling gaps.

When provoked, I can get positively long-winded.

Caste Issue

I sympathize with Arturo's revulsion against castes.

Bourgeois Efficacy

de Tocqueville speaks

Imaginatively Conceived

I'm referring, of course, to the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception.

Before The Fast

I've commented a few times on Fr. Stephen's blog here, here and here. The richness of his topics is bedazzling.

Condo Flippers Are Cheering

The residential real estate bailout is waiting for W's signature. Speculators in real estate and mortgage securities and the risk-management failures at Fannie and Freddie are in porcine heaven.

Marvelously Hypothetical

Today I had the privilege of listening to a bunch--a whole bunch--of masses composed by Josquin Des Prez, a Flemish Renaissance composer. Liturgically, his music is analogous to the best science fiction--a brilliantly wonderful hypothesis.

When I describe it as a hypothesis, I mean that despite the best efforts of our ecumenists, there's no reality there.

Ex Opere Operato

This is what a mechanistic sacrament produces.

Russian Royal Family

If any of you are uncomfortable with Orthodoxy's glorification of Czar Nicholas II and his family owing to your republican political leanings, run to Gabriel's important posting on the Royal Martyrs. It's not about politics, after all.

I'd be remiss without mentioning Father Stephen's recounting of the remarkable appearance of the Royal Family to some non-Orthodox during a car accident. I've linked to this posting previously.

Ensouled?

Religious vehemence about human sexuality often produces little light. Accordingly, the atheistic clinicians may have an advantage here.

Gabriel hosted a genteel discussion of Old Rome's Humanae Vitae, where I posted a comment intended to get us back to the basics about our fundamental ignorance about the nature of ensoulment.

Dolor, Pianto, E Penitenza

Pain, Lamentations, And Penitence

This is the song of the death procession, which made its debut in Florence's Carnival in 1511. It was innovative and not especially appropriate given its somberness in the midst of a festive atmosphere. I came across its performance by the Huelgas Ensemble while I was studying the annihilation of the Cathars in the Albigensian Crusade.

The Comedic Value Of Catholic Social Theory

Nothing makes a well-intentioned bishop look like an imbecile faster than his pontificating on issues related to political economy. That's my nutshell view of Catholic Social Theory.

Reality agrees with my disparagement. Hey, don't take my word for it. Take a gander at this hilarious news item.

More Squabbling

I decided to act like our leaders and engage in a little squabbling of my own. Gabriel and I have voiced our disagreements previously about Orthodoxy's pastoral approach to human sexuality. In short, I prefer the Orthodox approach.

For a third time, I voiced my support for the Squabbling of the Patriarchs.

The Virtue Of Squabbling

Moscow and Constantinople are squabbling again. Rather, I should say that they haven't stopped.

One dispute is about the EP's visit to the Ukraine. By the way, the Church in Ukraine is involved in its own controversy, of course, with a couple of schismatic churches as well as the Unia.

Another dispute concerns New Rome's primacy in Orthodoxy. Third Rome appears to believe in its superiority as defender of the Orthodox Faith over Constantinople.

I like the drama. Vehement defense of divergent views within the Church is healthy...and it's a clear sign that Orthodoxy isn't ossified.

Can You Dig It?

Two Fathers perform in a Russian rock festival.

Statecraft

The Wall Street Journal printed this quote from President Calvin Coolidge:

Governments do not make ideals, but ideals make governments. This is both historically and logically true. Of course the government can help to sustain ideals and can create institutions through which they can be the better observed, but their source by their very nature is in the people.

The people have to bear their own responsibilities. There is no method by which that burden can be shifted to the government. It is not the enactment, but the observance of laws, that creates the character of a nation.

In my view, anything said by Coolidge or his Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon, is worthy of consideration.

Global Warming As Hysteria?

Bret Stephens' latest piece on global warming in the Wall Street Journal is worth reading.

Critters

Fr. Stephen considers the non-human aspects of creation. After my usual commentary on human society, I briefly proposed the role of animals as agents of God's providence.

If my proposition is correct, then another question follows: are animals willing providential agents?

Holy Confessor Dositheus (Vasich), Metropolitan Of Zagreb

Orthodoxy and Alcoholics Anonymous

I've been fascinated by the success of the non-Orthodox self-help group Alcoholics Anonymous. In an area which is rife with failure, AA has eked out a remarkable sliver of victory. It's a spiritual program, but its spirituality is vaguely conceived.

Here's a three-part interview with Archimandrite Meletios: here, here, and here.

More Unified Disunity

Orthodixie reports on the latest ecumenical happenin'. The Unia proposed it, and the EP was polite.

Russians And Rights

Our Shepherds at the Bishops' Council haven't been resting on their laurels. They've released an important document about human rights here and here.

Quick Fast

I belong to a New-Calendar parish, and I was delighted with the short duration of the Apostles' Fast. Perhaps this compensates for the feeling that Pascha took forever to arrive this year.

While we're on the subject of calendars, I hear that converts tend to prefer adhering to the Old Calendar owing to fewer holiday conflicts with Western family members. You know, it's hard to simultaneously celebrate New-Calendar Christmas with your parish and biological families.

On a separate note, Gabriel considers the issue of reaching out to atheists. I'm not a big fan of that kind of outreach. Western Christianity has left a bad taste in folks' mouths through its denunciations, anti-intellectualism, and tyrannical impulses.

Destroyer Of Free Time

Father Stephen destroys my free time. Just when I resolve to get away from my computer for awhile, he posts something that compels my attention, and frequently, my comments. Experiences of eternity always grab my attention.

Duh-Side Economics

Some folks just don't understand economics. For those of you who are familiar with the quantity theory or perhaps you're just familiar with the drawbacks of the "general price level" fiction, this journalist's bewilderment is apt to draw a giggle or two.

Let me give you a hint. It's a terrific sign to me that monetary policy isn't overly expansive. Commodities will join real estate as tomorrow's has-beens...at least for a while.

I Always Thought That Hugs Were Suspect

The chimps know for sure.

Self-Doubt Is Okay

Just don't make it a habit.

Finally, Some Good News

Coffee drinkers have reason to cheer.

The Man With The Plan

Gabriel deserves my thanks for drawing my attention to the Fellowship of St. Alban and St. Sergius conference recording on AFR. His post deals mainly with Fr. Patrick Henry Reardon's lecture. Fr. Patrick ingeniously suggests that Orthodox would draw in more Evangelical converts by preaching more.

I think that it's a great idea, but, personally, I don't like most sermons I hear, and I don't like any sermons that last over ten minutes. I don't like Bible study, either. How's that for mixed feelings?

Makes Sense To Me

Cancer Stem Cells

Let's see what happens when human testing begins later this year.

Take A Few By Magritte, While You're At It

Good riddance.

I'm a Constable fan.

I Told You So

Unicorns exist.

Let's Call It Apostasy And Put It Behind Us

Romanian Metropolitan Nicolae of Banat communed with the Unia.

The Real Story About Church And State

Don't despair; God has shown us how to navigate the shoals.

Hitting The Nail On The Head

Some folks can't wear the world like a loose garment.

Arturo's Got It Goin' On...

...with his series on Pico della Mirandola. Here and here.

Mistreated Merchants

A discussion of the Frankish influence in Spain prompted my comment on the Reconquista.

More On AFR

Met. Phillip weighs in.

Dance

Not Another Useless Stimulus Plan, Please

President Bush is weighing more actions to stimulate the economy. Don't get me wrong. I liked receiving the money from the first tax "rebate", even though its questionable policy value resided in deficit-building and election-year PR. It added nothing to short-term stimulus or long-term growth.

Economic problems are solved through adjustments to entrepreneurs' unsuccessful plans. Policies should be designed to encourage flexibility and speed in making such adjustments. Alas, such policies may involve homeopathy rather than handouts and wouldn't be popular in election years.

Ignorance?

At an early age, I developed a devotion for Enlightenment thinkers and viewed postmoderns as mostly a circus sideshow, like the bearded lady or two-headed man. Imagine my surprise when I came across Orthodox whose view of the created world exhibited a postmodern Weltanschauung.

Too Soon to Herald A New Age?

Let's see how the emerging markets digest the slowdown in the developed markets first.

Heck, I Thought The Guy Was Funny

The RC priest who mocked Hillary at Obama's quondam church was told to go away for awhile.

He's too comical for anyone to care about his politics. I'd sing the Gloria in Latin for a free ticket to see his routine.

Clear Teaching--Straight Into The Trash Can

I've heard comments about Orthodoxy's "undeveloped" theology. I prefer underdevelopment to heterodoxy. As one Orthodox wit observed: "We don't need no stinkin' defined doctrines".

Andrea Elizabeth boldly confronted the ambiguities at Gabriel's inn.

Schismatics Are Folks, Too

I like this ROCiE video.

Toady's Limelight

There's something foul about the ingratitude of minions. Scott McClellan reminds me of George Stephanopoulos.

How did Shakespeare deal with this topic?

And A Speculator Is...?

Whenever some market goes up or goes down, which happens frequently, the market movement is attributed to speculators. I guess that someone has figured out that there's a difference between speculation and legitimate demand, but I don't get it. Ordinary folks don't get it, either, when they think they're being overcharged for a product or service.

Business involves buying cheap and selling dear, and that sounds speculation, too.

Does that make me anti-business or pro-speculation?

Go Aggies!

Och periodically covers agricultural issues. It'd be nice if outmoded agricultural techniques produced a lot of food for a given amount of labor expense, but they don't. Good riddance.

My Buddy Abelard

Here's an interesting post about hagiography's credibility. It's not really problematic for me, but I appreciated the opportunity to revisit the subject of Peter Abelard. Och never fails to amaze.

Rules Galore In An Ochlophobic Society

Czar Och is plumb crazy for regulations. All because of a single gnat, who, incidentally, provided me with a couple of chortles.

An Abundant Week

Fr. Stephen has joined Och and Gabriel in making this a fecund week of interesting perspectives. I've spoken about Och and Gabriel earlier, and I commented on a couple of subjects that have been fermenting for a while.

Let me emphasize something. As you know, I support political and economic systems that acknowledge human freedom. The fact that aspects of our society are tawdry and downright sinful isn't the fault of human freedom or the systemization of those freedoms, but is the fault of particular individuals who behave in a tawdry and sinful manner, but most especially, of particular officials who lack the courage to coordinate our public morality with Orthodox teachings. Laws don't exist as a meaningless showpiece, but as the assertion of a society's moral truths.

More on this later. Aren't you excited?

I Commend To Your Attention

Two worthwhile posts covering disparate topics.

Micro Issues

The Church will develop confidence in speaking about those secular issues facing society by successfully confronting the secular world in such mundane areas as providing for parishes' material well-being. In America, we don't have a Czar on whom to rely for material sustenance. Yes, the Church will have to roll up her sleeves in utilitarian pursuits, which is what Christ did.

No Heart For Hart

Unlike other Orthodox, I found Hart's Christ or Nothing offensive. With regard to his social commentary, he's an empty suit. On the other hand, his style is golden, especially when he's dumping on his professorial competitors. All God's chillun got wings.

Time To 'Fess Up

I voted for Ron Paul.

His economics is too first-rate.

Patriarch Bartholomew could use a little economics like Paul's.

Finally, A Smoking Gun

Some of you have heard my view about the OCA's financial scandal. My view, until now, has been simple:

(1) My effort to dig through the screeching commentary to find some kind of facts resulted in ambiguous evidence that didn't necessarily point to wrongdoing and

(2) Parishes that withhold money from their Bishops and Church on the basis of screeching commentary and innuendo are disloyal.

Finally, I've received the evidence for which I was looking. A friend sent me the OCA's report that was published briefly online. It's now located here.

An American Patriarch? Ask the Greeks

Och has a conversation underway about American Orthodoxy. I didn't mention this over there, but I actually like competing jurisdictions wherein parishes have to be welcoming and friendly to attract newcomers and converts. Naw, that idea's too Protestant to be really Christian.

Catching Up


Here's a comment about how secular traditions don't arise in an economic vacuum.

As I opined on Och's blog, this year's Lent was disappointing, but I imagine that disappointment is part of the martyrdom that Lent cultivates.

Part of my disappointment was tied to my inability to refrain all blog activity during Lent. When a chorus of criticism was directed against Ancient Faith Radio, my hackles were raised. Added to that was a tongue-in-cheek attack on my beloved Obikhod and on AFR as Ortho-Protestantism. Listen, AFR is the closest thing to Mom and apple pie in my book.

I switched to Gabriel's blog to begin presenting a view that the Church/State symphonia is simply a manifestation of a larger clergy/laity relationship. Under our republican government, the parish and diocesan council replaces the Emperor as the laity's representative. For this partnership to be effective, there must be cooperation as well as constraint.

More about symphonia here.

This makes me a card-carrying supply-sider fellow-traveler. Yes, I add Laffer curver to my portfolio. Wordsmythes, be nice.

Just When You Thought That Good Economics Was Consigned To The Woodwork

The Federal Reserve's moves to prop up Bear Stearns Cos. will come to be seen as "the worst policy mistake in a generation," the former head of monetary affairs at the Fed.

The action is comparable to "the great contraction" of the 1930s and "the great inflation" of the 1970s, said Vincent Reinhart, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, who retired from the Fed last fall.

God Delights In The Death Of His Saints

"Many times I have seen the reflection of Your glory on the faces of the dead. What unearthly beauty and joy shone from them; how ethereal and immaterial were their features. This is the triumph of happiness and peace received gracefully, as they silently call upon You. At the hour of my death also illumine my soul as I call: Alleluia! "

Kontakion 12
Akathist of Thanksgiving
Fr. Gregory Petroff

My Buddy

NYC pub owner bans `Danny Boy' in March

In The Beginning Was Bill Buckley

Memory Eternal.

1389?

``I mean, after all, we're talking about something from 1389 - 1389. It's time to move forward.''

Funny, I hadn't considered that option.

No One Saw This Coming

Kosovo Serb protesters attack UN police

I May Get In Trouble For This One

Gabriel solicited suggestions about his Lenten reading, but strayed dangerously (for me) into blaming various characters for their parts in the decline of Western Civilization. I'm elated at his targeting of Rousseau and Marx, but uncertain about Nietzsche. I blame Nietzsche for Freud, or maybe Freud for Freud, but I don't blame Nietzsche for the Nazis. I do blame Nietzsche's sister for the Nazis.

Anyway, given my preoccupation with the relationship of Church and State, I expressed an interest in the formative role of the Roman Catholic Church in shaping young Hitler's and Himmler's minds. Likewise, I'm interested in the formative role of the Orthodox Church in shaping young Stalin's mind.

Offhand, I can't think of a Protestant tyrant, other than Cromwell, but I'll keep looking.

Anyone who's read my posts and comments knows that I have little patience for Orthodox who think that an Orthodox Tsar would be the best leader for an Orthodox State. In fact, it's certainly possible that the close identification of the Russian Orthodox Church with Russian Czar created the impression that both institutions' goals were identical. Frankly, I'd like to see the Orthodox Church as the established state church in states with republican or limited monarchical governments and free economies. A closer intertwining, in my view, would breed a decadence and backlash that doesn't help anyone.

I Guess Utilitarianism Is Bad

I'm amused when folks speak longingly about the age of chivalry, for underlying such longings is the unmindfulness of the economic infrastructure that supports the noble caste's leisure. The human capital providing economic support was, of course, some form of coercive economic servitude. We've seen this kind of magical chivalric existence in the modern era--Czarist Russia and the Antebellum South. Some of the costs associated with maintaining the structure of coercive parasitism were imposed on the society at large, and those citizens too were excluded from the chivalric dream of a few.

By the way, the "leisure" of Ancient Greece was supported by economic actors excluded from its "democracy".

Kingdom Consciousness

A little while ago I suspected that Och might get this topic going, and I've spent a little time thinking about Joel Osteen.

It's true; I like Osteen. He's pleasant and upbeat. He's kind and considerate. He wants folks to succeed.

His prosperity message is very Old Testament, wherein God's favor is demonstrated by material prosperity, and His disfavor...well, just ask the Noah or the Sodomites.

The only problem is that Christ came along and showed us that sometimes things aren't so simple. Orthodox Christians are especially aware of the phenomenon known as martyrdom--in which material failure veils spiritual success.

I'm having trouble finding the Kingdom in Osteenism.

Early Presidential Discussions

Och announces his preference. Comments appear to favor Ron Paul. Not bad, but what about foreign policy?

Nazi-Supported Independent State of Croatia

An Orthodox blogger questioned the connection of my comment regarding the Serbian Holocaust in Croatia during World War II and his posting regarding the 75th anniversary of Adolf Hilter's rise to power.

I can sort of understand why the connection would appear to be tenuous, since the popular culture's idea of Hitlerian Big Events doesn't include atrocities in an obscure European corner.

Hilter permitted the Ustashe (a Croatian nationalist organization) to create the Independent State of Croatia, which proceeded to kill, deport, and forcibly convert to Roman Catholicism hundreds of thousands of Orthodox Serbs. The leading Latin prelate in Croatia, Archbishop (later Cardinal) Stepinac, supported the forced conversions. Interestingly, Stepinac was beatified by Pope John Paul II, who ironically was a keen advocate of Latin/Orthodox ecumenism. Many Latin priests and monks participated in the atrocities.

The US Holocaust Museum website has information about the third largest concentration camp in Europe, Jasenovac, whose sometime commander was a Franciscan priest. The Serbian Orthodox Church website has information about this unfortunate period.


"Because of your faith in God and God's justice,
ye have suffered earthly sorrow in the flesh;
yet ye saved your souls, as heaven rejoices and your ancestors sin our in Heaven,
greeting you at the gate of Paradise in son;
Your names are in the book of eternity,
enter into Paradise, ye children of immortality!
Therefore we on earth, your posterity, cry out in unison:
Holy New Martyrs, pray for us."

Troparion of the New Martyrs of Serbia, Tone 8
(Composed by St. Nikolai (Velimirovich))

My Hero

Orthodixie's interview

Don't Beat Around The Bush, Pretty Please

It must be hunting season somewhere. That's why I loaded 00 buck here and here.

Potpourri

Ecumenism and economics

Me Loves Putin, But Just For Today

Now, will the West continue to kick Serbia with impunity?

You make me feel like dancing,
I wanna dance the night away...

This comment is too autobiographical, but I got carried away by Och's return.

I Wish That I Had Said Something Earlier

Gabriel has written a series of posts on limits. I've wanted to comment on some of them, but time contradicted my desire. After he expressed frustration at the whole subject, I found the time for a small comment.

Why isn't anyone surprised at this one?

Catholics play vital role in helping migrants to US

Me Loves Maxim

Och praises Maxim, and so do I.

Now We're Seeing Some REAL Christianity

Serbia's parliament overwhelmingly voted to tie the issue of EU and NATO membership to the status of Kosovo-Metohija. It's about time, and it's just what the doctor ordered.

Few Westerners have heard of the Metohija part of Kosovo-Metohija, and it's too much for anyone to expect that vapid network journalists would perform any intellectual heavy lifting, despite their pretentions.

Metohija means "Church lands", and this is the part of Kosovo-Metohija that is so rich in Orthodox history, churches, and monasteries.

Feast your mind on this writer and and this wonderful piece.

Incidentally, for all of the trash-talking about Vladimir Putin, he's been steadfast in his support of the Orthodox solution in Kosovo-Metohija.

As a personal aside, I am particularly fascinated with Serbia and Serbian Orthodoxy since Serbia's variation on Church/State symphonia involved a limited monarchy, rather than the more archetypical absolutist variety. I really get tired of Orthodox folks who think that Czars and such are the only truly Orthodox rulers.

Little Lent Arrived Too Soon

A promising discussion was brewing over at Och's blog, but the Calendar will force me to cut my participation way short.

Another Useless Comment, Perhaps

I don't know why I even got involved in this one. Maybe it was the sloppiness of the syllogism. Maybe it was reference to majority votes and the Will to Power. Hmmmm, do you think that the Vatican knows something about the latter?

Just Walk Away and Pretend It Didn't Happen

Och is ready to sign the commitment papers....

Folks, He's On A Roll

Gabriel has surpassed himself with his latest post. Wow, I believe that he's becoming positively visionary. Being visionary is part of being Orthodox, of course. We aren't wordsmiths; we're imagesmiths.

I don't understand his guilt thing, but as long as he sticks to the program, he'll get over that soon enough.

Ecumenism, Again

I'm glad we're just talking about it.

Get comfy; it's a long post.

Technolust Abstinence

I'm getting a little impatient with guys' hunching over computer monitors denouncing technology. Maybe by making that statement I'm presenting an unjust caricature, but sometimes the amorphously sentimental utopianism gets so thick that I can't see something more noble.

Someone diverted the issue with a reference to spousal abuse, and I took hold of that opportunity with gusto.

Potter Prattle

I couldn't resist. I had to ask Gabriel whether those popular stories are off-limits to his new flock.

Letting off Ecumenical Steam

I get so tired of the Latinist folks who profess to desire ecumenism with the Orthodox but continue to prattle on about defined doctrines, canonical validity, and such. The plain fact is that they don't understand Orthodoxy. If there's such a thing as a Latinist mindset, is its source to be found in the filioque?

Ad Orientem mentioned the Traditional Anglican Communion's talks with Old Rome. I had heard some time ago that TAC was looking for a Uniat-style relationship. Then again, maybe they need to trade in that jalopy for a wholly new model.

Just Call Me Uncle Dutch

You know, just when I've resolved to be more pleasant and charitable in my Internet interactions, someone says something that stimulates me to issue a strong response. This time, Gabriel hit a couple of my hot buttons, and I thank him for the opportunity to sort out some of these issues in my own mind.

Usually, this blog is ten leagues above my head, but I felt comfortable today, with Fr. Paul Tarazi's erudition keeping me afloat.

Yeah, it's not widely known, but Orthodox actually read the Bible.

Speculative Me

I've blessed Fr. Stephen with another comment. This time, I'm talking about finitude and scarcity. It seems obvious to me that finitude and its material counterpart, scarcity, is an inescapable part of both fallen and unfallen man's existence. I opined that fullness could signify the irrelevance of scarcity.

East is East, and West is West

Give me a break. I am so tired of the East vs. West argument that gets argued as if it's about something other than the acceptance of theological error by the Patriarch of the West. In my mind, this issue is really pretty simple.

Theologians ≠ Quants

Who'd have thunk it? Theologians aren't known for their quantitative orientation.

I was treated to a brief discussion of Orthodoxy by a noted quant, Nassim Nicholas Taleb.

Better yet, read the whole thing.

Catechisms and Anglicanisms

Fr. Stephen has expressed his intention of writing an Orthodox catechism. I commented in forthright fashion.

Well...at least he'll be able to testify at Judgment that I once gave him a cup of cold water.

While I'm on the subject of Fr. Stephen, let me sing his praises for a moment. He's a good example of what I love about Anglican-tradition believers and, especially, Anglican-tradition converts to Orthodoxy. He and I agree on little other than Orthodoxy, but he brings to the table articulate erudition, good humor, and collegiality. He's a real pastor, and, as a bonus, his parish's nave is pewless.

Sympathizing with the secularists

The Ochlophobist opened up the evolutionism/creationism can of worms, and I couldn't resist voicing my meager opinion. I further made my sympathies known over at Gabriel's site.

I congratulate Gabriel on his new employment.

I'm sorry to hear that the Ochlophobist is becoming anti-science. You know, I think a lot of confusion about science and Orthodoxy would be solved if we were able, through some simple technique, to erase the unwholesome influence that the Western heresies have had in framing the religion/science issue. The solution, of course, is more Orthodoxy, but that isn't implemented simply.

My view is that the evolutionism/creationism controversy is simple, rather than grandiose. It only seems grandiose because of the disingenuousness of some folks involved in the controversy.

Let me be plain about this: my sympathies lie with Truth and with particular truths. Scientists who endorse evolutionism are merely picking the best explanation out of a sorry lot, and man's life in the created world often involves such tradeoffs. Man is endowed with reason, not omniscience. Scientists necessarily hold a truncated view of reality--that is, a view of reality that includes only the created world--because they are doing science, not theology.

The creationism and ID folks aren't grappling with issues like intellectual honesty, but rather foisting their perversely nominal Christianity on every endeavor, including science.

Give me the sparkling prose of an anguished soul like Christopher Hitchens. For that matter, I like Camille Paglia, too.

Maybe I love absolute monarchy after all?

Yeah, right, but I posted this little comment about the OCA scandal over at The Ochlophobist. I wish someone would tell me something about the scandal that would upset me, because, right now, I am yawning.

Perhaps I should read some Fr. Schmemann so I can contribute to the real discussion.

Coming off the Dormition Fast, I thought that I'd agree with the Ochlophobist about having less in a world of more. Don't count on any other agreements, however.

Am I being dull-minded about particular rarified topics? For example, I don't see a lot of good coming out of evil, but some folks do. I don't see a lot of higher meanings, either.

I've come across a new blog wherein the owner expounds on man's free will and God's foreknowledge. Good stuff for folks who have their metaphysical priorities straight.

With new ground to explore, my empirical antennae began to quiver. I asked questions here and here. It doesn't take me too long to get down to brass tacks.